Gray v Elite Town Management [2016] EWCA Civ 1318 — Court of Appeal
Surveyors balance statutory rights with the duty not to cause unnecessary inconvenience; jurisdiction remains bounded by the Act.
Party Wall section 10 case law on surveyor appointments, jurisdiction, awards, third surveyors, fees and appeals.
Section 10 contains the Act’s dispute-resolution machinery. It governs appointments, the two-surveyor and agreed-surveyor routes, third surveyors, awards, costs and the statutory appeal. It is therefore central to much of the modern case law.
Surveyors balance statutory rights with the duty not to cause unnecessary inconvenience; jurisdiction remains bounded by the Act.
Reinforces the boundary between statutory dispute resolution and court litigation.
Service is substantive because it starts a very short appeal period.
Ex parte powers are exceptional and their statutory conditions must exist when exercised.
Section 10 is not a free-standing jurisdiction over every dispute connected with notifiable work.
Surveyors cannot determine or fund through an award matters lying wholly outside the Act.
Use the statutory appeal route promptly rather than assuming a collateral challenge is safer.
Unappealed awards can have serious enforcement consequences.
A later valid statutory process can have consequences different from a unilateral attempt to impose the Act where no notice is ever served.
Explains in detail why s10 does not create a general neighbour-dispute tribunal.
An award being conclusive does not cure unclear drafting or create an obligation it does not contain.
Fee disputes turn on reasonableness, work actually required and evidence.
The final statutory day runs to the end of the day, but valid filing and fee requirements remain essential; extensions require exceptional circumstances.
Consequential compensation needs evidence; it is not automatically limited to physical repair.
s7(2) is itself capable of generating a dispute under s10.
Published hourly rates alone do not determine recoverability; necessity and proportionality matter.
An award should authorise only works for which the Act supplies a right.
An appointment does not create an everlasting mandate over all future issues.
Historic predecessor-legislation authority on the definition of owner and strict compliance when acting ex parte.
Use the later Court of Appeal decision for binding propositions.
Do not assume calling an award 'void' removes all procedural/limitation difficulties.
Appointed surveyors are not ordinary client advocates when exercising statutory functions.
Do not assume every s10(17) appeal operates like a conventional narrow judicial review.
Not every procedural objection can safely be kept in reserve after active participation.
Not every procedural imperfection makes an award void.
Preliminary jurisdiction points can dispose of substantial parts of a dispute.
Private agreements cannot safely be assumed to disapply statutory requirements.
Consent is not the end of the Act if a later statutory damage/compensation dispute arises.
Section 10 appointment powers are prescriptive and should not be improvised.
Procedural objections should be made promptly, not after participating on a contrary basis.
Boundary ownership questions are not automatically transformed into s10 disputes.
Notice defects and jurisdiction should be considered together with what the parties subsequently did.
Courts do not set aside awards merely because a party prefers a different technical view.
Compensation is not a blank cheque; reasonableness and mitigation matter.
Appointment challenges depend heavily on the statutory steps and evidence of what the parties actually agreed.