Party Wall Case Law Library

Maddows v Fernandez

28 Sep 2020

PersuasiveSpecialist

Case in one sentence: Do not assume every s10(17) appeal operates like a conventional narrow judicial review.

Why this case matters

Maddows v Fernandez concerns an important practical question: Is the appeal a review or rehearing, and how should the court approach the award? The decision discusses the appellate approach in the statutory context. Practical significance: Do not assume every s10(17) appeal operates like a conventional narrow judicial review.

What happened

Appeal concerned a third-surveyor award and the correct approach of the county court on appeal.

Question before the court

Is the appeal a review or rehearing, and how should the court approach the award?

Decision

The decision discusses the appellate approach in the statutory context.

What it means in practice

Do not assume every s10(17) appeal operates like a conventional narrow judicial review.

What the case does not decide

This decision should not be extended beyond the issue and factual setting described above. Different notices, appointments, works, evidence or procedural history may produce a different result.

Building-owner lesson

Prepare the evidential case early if an award may be appealed.

Adjoining-owner lesson

Act within 14 days and understand the appeal's procedural character.

Surveyor lesson

Make a reasoned award capable of scrutiny on the evidence and law.

Key passages / points

Read alongside Zissis for appellate procedure.

Related cases

Zissis v Lukomski; Basu v Baron

Important legal disclaimer

This case-law resource is provided by Coburns Party Wall for general information and educational purposes only. It is not legal advice and is not a substitute for advice on the facts of a particular matter. Case summaries necessarily simplify decisions, and the relevance or precedential weight of a case may depend on the court, later decisions, the wording of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 and the particular facts. Unreported and County Court decisions may be persuasive rather than binding. Obtain appropriate professional or legal advice before applying any case to a live dispute.