Gray v Elite Town Management [2016] EWCA Civ 1318 — Court of Appeal
Surveyors balance statutory rights with the duty not to cause unnecessary inconvenience; jurisdiction remains bounded by the Act.
Key Party Wall case law on surveyor jurisdiction: when section 10 applies, what surveyors can determine, and the limits of an award.
Surveyors appointed under the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 exercise statutory functions. These cases explore when that jurisdiction exists, what matters can be determined within an award, and where a dispute remains for the courts or ordinary property law.
Surveyors balance statutory rights with the duty not to cause unnecessary inconvenience; jurisdiction remains bounded by the Act.
Ex parte powers are exceptional and their statutory conditions must exist when exercised.
Section 10 is not a free-standing jurisdiction over every dispute connected with notifiable work.
Surveyors cannot determine or fund through an award matters lying wholly outside the Act.
Claims against surveyors personally are distinct from statutory appeals against awards.
Unappealed awards can have serious enforcement consequences.
Explains in detail why s10 does not create a general neighbour-dispute tribunal.
A later award cannot automatically absorb liability for an earlier common-law wrong.
s7(2) is itself capable of generating a dispute under s10.
An award should authorise only works for which the Act supplies a right.
An appointment does not create an everlasting mandate over all future issues.
Party-wall administration cannot substitute for resolving disputed ownership of the boundary.
Party-wall litigation can generate substantial collateral damages issues outside the surveyors' jurisdiction.
Do not assume calling an award 'void' removes all procedural/limitation difficulties.
Compensation provisions must be read according to who is entitled and the statutory source of the claim.
Appointed surveyors are not ordinary client advocates when exercising statutory functions.
Not every procedural imperfection makes an award void.
Preliminary jurisdiction points can dispose of substantial parts of a dispute.
Complexity does not enlarge surveyors' jurisdiction beyond the Act.
Useful historically but Power v Shah now supplies binding modern jurisdiction guidance.
Boundary ownership questions are not automatically transformed into s10 disputes.
Notice defects and jurisdiction should be considered together with what the parties subsequently did.
Still useful for the principle that statutory surveyors cannot invent powers, but wording of predecessor legislation must be handled cautiously.