Browse by topic

Party Wall Damage and Compensation

Party Wall damage and compensation case law on causation, repair costs, mitigation, consequential loss and section 7(2).

What this topic covers

Damage disputes require more than showing that a defect appeared after works began. These cases examine causation, the reasonable scope of repair, mitigation and the different heads of loss that may arise under section 7(2) or at common law.

Questions these cases help answer

  • What loss was caused by the works?
  • What repair is reasonably required?
  • What evidence supports consequential loss or mitigation?

Cases on this topic

Roadrunner Properties Ltd v Dean

[2003] EWCA Civ 1816; costs order [2004] EWCA Civ 376 · Court of Appeal · Binding

Failure to use the Act can remove contemporaneous safeguards and make later factual disputes harder.

Seeff v Ho

[2011] EWCA Civ 186; 24 Feb 2011 · Court of Appeal · Binding

Garden-fence consent is not a substitute for proper statutory and planning procedures.

Taylor v Jones; Taylor v Spriggs

[2024] EWCA Civ 170; 28 Feb 2024 · Court of Appeal · Binding

Post-work damage does not automatically make the building owner liable for curing every pre-existing defect.

Rodrigues v Sokal

[2008] EWHC 2005 (TCC); 30 Jul 2008 · High Court/TCC · High Court

A later valid statutory process can have consequences different from a unilateral attempt to impose the Act where no notice is ever served.

Ash v Trimnell-Ritchard

19 Nov 2020 · County Court · Persuasive

Water ingress cases require evidence of source and causal mechanism, not assumptions based on timing.

Breuer v Leccacorvi

11 Feb 2014 · Central London County Court · Persuasive

Measure of loss depends on the actual loss and reasonableness of the proposed remedy.

Chliaichfchtein v Wainbridge

26 Apr 2018 · Central London County Court · Persuasive

Consequential compensation needs evidence; it is not automatically limited to physical repair.

Kelliher v Ash Estates Holding Ltd

15 Jul 2013 · Central London County Court · Persuasive

Damage claims may extend beyond a crack repair, but each head needs a legal and evidential basis.

Onigbanjo v Pearson

20 Jun 2008; Mayor's & City of London Court · County Court · Persuasive

Consent is not the end of the Act if a later statutory damage/compensation dispute arises.

Welter v McKeeve

27 Nov 2018 · Central London County Court · Persuasive

Compensation is not a blank cheque; reasonableness and mitigation matter.

← Browse all Party Wall case-law topics