Gray v Elite Town Management [2016] EWCA Civ 1318 — Court of Appeal
Surveyors balance statutory rights with the duty not to cause unnecessary inconvenience; jurisdiction remains bounded by the Act.
Party Wall section 7 case law on compensation, unnecessary inconvenience, damage and special foundations.
Section 7 contains important protections and limitations, including compensation for loss or damage, the duty to avoid unnecessary inconvenience and restrictions concerning special foundations. These cases show how those questions arise in practice.
Surveyors balance statutory rights with the duty not to cause unnecessary inconvenience; jurisdiction remains bounded by the Act.
Post-work damage does not automatically make the building owner liable for curing every pre-existing defect.
s7(2) is a compensation provision requiring careful causal and quantum analysis.
A later valid statutory process can have consequences different from a unilateral attempt to impose the Act where no notice is ever served.
Measure of loss depends on the actual loss and reasonableness of the proposed remedy.
Whether a foundation is 'special' depends on its actual construction, not merely the presence of reinforcement somewhere in the scheme.
Consequential compensation needs evidence; it is not automatically limited to physical repair.
s7(2) is itself capable of generating a dispute under s10.
Use the later Court of Appeal decision for binding propositions.
Compensation provisions must be read according to who is entitled and the statutory source of the claim.
Compensation is not a blank cheque; reasonableness and mitigation matter.